Carl Gaertner Paintings: Auction Prices

American · 1898–1952

ArtSell has recorded 2 auction results for Carl Gaertner paintings between 2004 and 2024, of which 2 sold (100% sell-through). Prices realised range from $1,700 to $3,100, with a median of $2,400 across 2 priced sales (USD at the sale-date rate). A further 5 lots offered at auction whose result the house did not publish are listed but not counted. The highest recorded price is $3,100 for “Lewis Hollow” at Sloans & Kenyon in 2004.

Record: Lewis Hollow — $3,100Sign up free to see

Price chart & statistics for Carl Gaertner →

All paintings results

1. 
   Pine Point Spur

   Oil · Board

   Rachel Davis Fine Arts · Mar 22, 2025 · Lot 157
   Result not publishedEst. $3,000–5,000View at Rachel Davis Fine Arts ↗
2. 
   Bermuda

   Oil · Board

   11 x 14 in

   Rachel Davis Fine Arts · Oct 19, 2024 · Lot 354A
   $1,700≈ £1,303≈ €1,567HammerSign up free to seeEst. $1,000–2,000View at Rachel Davis Fine Arts ↗
3. 
   - Still-Life-

   Oil · Canvas

   Rachel Davis Fine Arts · Oct 19, 2019 · Lot 172
   Result not publishedEst. $400–600View at Rachel Davis Fine Arts ↗
4. 
   - Cabin in The Woods-

   Oil · Canvas

   Rachel Davis Fine Arts · Oct 20, 2018 · Lot 222
   Result not publishedEst. $600–900View at Rachel Davis Fine Arts ↗
5. 
   - Artist's Pallette-

   Oil · Panel

   Rachel Davis Fine Arts · Oct 24, 2015 · Lot 355
   Result not publishedEst. $200–400View at Rachel Davis Fine Arts ↗
6. 
   - Fall Landscape with Mountains and Stream-

   Oil · Board

   Rachel Davis Fine Arts · Oct 24, 2015 · Lot 344
   Result not publishedEst. $1,000–2,000View at Rachel Davis Fine Arts ↗
7. 
   Lewis Hollow

   Oil · Panel

   Sloans & Kenyon · May 7, 2004 · Lot 1725
   $3,100≈ £1,725≈ €2,568HammerSign up free to seeEst. $6,000–8,000View at Sloans & Kenyon ↗

Other media by Carl Gaertner

Works on PaperOil PaintingsWatercolorsGouachesDrawings

All Carl Gaertner auction results → · Own a painting by Carl Gaertner? Get a free auction estimate →