Nancy Tuttle May Paintings: Value & Auction Prices

b. 1940

Nancy Tuttle May paintings have appeared at auction 19 times in ArtSell’s records between 2024 and 2026; 19 sold, a sell-through rate of 100%. Half of the priced sales fell between $375Sign up free to see and $1.4kSign up free to see, with a median of $800Sign up free to see. The auction record in our data is Window to the Soul, sold at Leland Little in April 2026 for $8.5kSign up free to see. Sales were recorded mainly at Leland Little (16) and Ahlers & Ogletree (3).

Price chart & statistics for Nancy Tuttle May →

All paintings results

1. 
   Dream Journey Series

   Oil · Canvas

   36 x 36 in.

   Leland Little · Jul 23, 2026 · Lot 3003
   $850≈ £637≈ €746HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
2. 
   Blue Mists

   Oil · Canvas

   30 x 30 in.

   Leland Little · Jul 23, 2026 · Lot 3002
   $700≈ £524≈ €614HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
3. 
   Colors of Summer

   Oil · Canvas

   24 x 48 in.

   Leland Little · Jul 23, 2026 · Lot 3001
   $750≈ £562≈ €658HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
4. 
   Ravissant

   Oil · Canvas

   40 x 20 in.

   Leland Little · Apr 30, 2026 · Lot 2007
   $8,000≈ £5,922≈ €6,836HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
5. 
   Ravissant

   Oil · Canvas

   40 x 20 in.

   Leland Little · Apr 30, 2026 · Lot 2006
   $1,500≈ £1,110≈ €1,282HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
6. 
   Forever Green

   Mixed media · Canvas

   40 x 40 in.

   Leland Little · Apr 30, 2026 · Lot 2005
   $1,400≈ £1,036≈ €1,196HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
7. 
   Spring's Promise

   Mixed media · Canvas

   40 x 40 in.

   Leland Little · Apr 30, 2026 · Lot 2003
   $1,600≈ £1,184≈ €1,367HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
8. 
   Window to the Soul

   Mixed media · Canvas

   48 x 36 in.

   Leland Little · Apr 30, 2026 · Lot 2002
   $8,500≈ £6,292≈ €7,264HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
9. 
   Changes in Latitudes

   Mixed media · Canvas

   48 x 48 in.

   Leland Little · Apr 30, 2026 · Lot 2001
   $1,500≈ £1,110≈ €1,282HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
10. 
    Dansant Series II, III, and IV Triptych

    Mixed media · Canvas

    13 x 13 in.

    Leland Little · Apr 16, 2026 · Lot 3350
    $350≈ £258≈ €297HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
11. 
    Untitled

    Mixed media

    11 x 14.75 in

    Ahlers & Ogletree · Feb 20, 2026 · Lot 757
    $100≈ £74≈ €85HammerSign up free to seeEst. $100–200View at Ahlers & Ogletree ↗
12. 
    Untitled

    Mixed media

    22.5 x 16 in

    Ahlers & Ogletree · Feb 20, 2026 · Lot 759
    $225≈ £167≈ €191HammerSign up free to seeEst. $500–700View at Ahlers & Ogletree ↗
13. 
    Santa Fe Series II" - late 20th century

    Mixed media

    11 x 30 in

    Ahlers & Ogletree · Feb 20, 2026 · Lot 818
    $125≈ £93≈ €106HammerSign up free to seeEst. $400–600View at Ahlers & Ogletree ↗
14. 
    Vermillion Quest

    Mixed media

    15 1/4 x 11 in.

    Leland Little · Feb 19, 2026 · Lot 3471
    $800≈ £595≈ €681HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
15. 
    Petite Jewel I

    Oil · Canvas

    9 x 12 in.

    Leland Little · Jul 24, 2025 · Lot 3035
    $400≈ £295≈ €340HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
16. 
    Color Strata / Freeing the Line

    Acrylic

    30 x 22 1/2 in.

    Leland Little · May 1, 2025 · Lot 4034
    $900≈ £674≈ €791HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
17. 
    Almost Perfect Silence / Silence Perfected

    Oil · Canvas

    36 x 24 in.

    Leland Little · May 1, 2025 · Lot 4033
    $650≈ £487≈ €572HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
18. 
    Depth of the Unknown

    Mixed media · Canvas

    44 1/2 x 47 in.

    Leland Little · Jan 30, 2025 · Lot 6003
    $800≈ £644≈ €769HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗
19. 
    Golden Lights

    Mixed media · Canvas

    11 x 14 in.

    Leland Little · Oct 17, 2024 · Lot 3046
    $175≈ £134≈ €161HammerSign up free to seeView at Leland Little ↗

Other media by Nancy Tuttle May

Works on PaperOil PaintingsMixed MediaWatercolors

All Nancy Tuttle May auction results →