Price databaseBrowseWhat’s it worth?Sell your artworkAppraisals
Watchlist

Theodore Earl Butler Oil Paintings: Value & Auction Prices

1861–1936

Theodore Earl Butler oil paintings have appeared at auction 26 times in ArtSell’s records between 2006 and 2025; 15 sold, a sell-through rate of 58%. The median price realised is $31.6kSign up free to see across 15 priced sales; the middle half sold for $20.3kSign up free to see–$34.9kSign up free to see. The highest recorded price is $553kSign up free to see for Flag Day at Bonhams in November 2018. Most results come from Bonhams (20), Brunk Auctions (5) and Coeur d'Alene Art Auction (1).

$552,500≈ £430,732≈ €483,504Sign uprecord price · incl. premiumFlag DayBonhams26auction results2006–2025years recorded58%sold$31.6kSign up free to seemedian price

Theodore Earl Butler oil paintings: key figures

Auction results
26
Sold rate
58%
Active at auction
2006–2025
Median price
$31.6kSign up free to see
Record price
$553kSign up free to see Flag Day, Bonhams, Nov 2018

Top auction houses: Bonhams (20), Brunk Auctions (5), Coeur d'Alene Art Auction (1)

Price guide: what is a work by Theodore Earl Butler worth? →

Selling? How to sell a work by Theodore Earl Butler: free estimate, costs and timeline →

Own a work by Theodore Earl Butler? What’s it worth: compare similar past results by medium and size →

Need an appraisal for insurance? Request a written Theodore Earl Butler appraisal →

Typical range is the middle half of priced sales (USD at the sale-date rate). Past auction results, not a valuation.

Price chart & statistics for Theodore Earl Butler →

All oil paintings results

Sign up free to see all prices. You’ve seen the free realized prices for this month. Artist, title, date, house, medium, size and estimates stay visible to everyone. Create a free account · Sign in
  1. The Bridge near Giverny by Theodore Earl Butler, 1909, oil on canvas, offered Nov 2025
    The Bridge near Giverny, 1909
    Oil · Canvas
    23 3/4 x 28 3/4 in. (60.3 x 73 cm.)
    Bonhams · · Lot 39
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $15,000–25,000View at Bonhams ↗
  2. Le Tréport Fireworks by Theodore Earl Butler, 1908, oil on canvas laid down on board, offered Nov 2025
    Le Tréport Fireworks, 1908
    Oil · Canvas
    19 1/2 x 25 3/8 in. (49.5 x 64.4 cm.), oval
    Bonhams · · Lot 37
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $10,000–15,000View at Bonhams ↗
  3. Sailboats, Upper Bay, New York by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on canvas, sold Nov 2024
    Sailboats, Upper Bay, New York
    Oil · Canvas
    31 3/4 x 40in
    Bonhams · · Lot 80
    $28,160≈ £22,266≈ €26,621Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $15,000–25,000View at Bonhams ↗
  4. Church, Giverny, 1896
    Oil · Canvas
    23 ½ x 29 in.
    Brunk Auctions · · Lot 753
    $26,000≈ £19,948≈ €23,860HammerSign up free to seeEst. $30,000–50,000View at Brunk Auctions ↗
  5. Scene from an Amateur Play, Giverny by Theodore Earl Butler, 1910, oil on canvas, sold May 2024
    Scene from an Amateur Play, Giverny, 1910
    Oil · Canvas
    46 1/4 x 46 1/4 in. (117.5 x 117.5 cm.)
    Bonhams · · Lot 28
    $35,840≈ £28,583≈ €33,439Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $30,000–50,000View at Bonhams ↗
  6. Veules-les-Roses by Theodore Earl Butler, circa 1904-1905, oil on canvas, sold May 2024
    Veules-les-Roses, circa 1904-1905
    Oil · Canvas
    22 x 15 7/8 in. (55.9 x 40.3 cm.)
    Bonhams · · Lot 27
    $21,760≈ £17,354≈ €20,302Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $15,000–25,000View at Bonhams ↗
  7. Le Porte de New York by Theodore Earl Butler, 1917, oil on canvas, offered May 2024
    Le Porte de New York, 1917
    Oil · Canvas
    31 1/2 x 44 in. (80 x 111.8 cm.)
    Bonhams · · Lot 26
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $20,000–30,000View at Bonhams ↗
  8. Untitled by Theodore Earl Butler, Oil On Canvas, 1904, "The Train", offered Sep 2023
    Untitled
    Oil · Canvas
    H 22.25" W 28.25"
    DuMouchelles · · Lot 1038
    Result not publishedEst. $12,000–18,000View at DuMouchelles ↗
  9. Valley of the Seine, Giverny by Theodore Earl Butler, 1912, oil on canvas, sold May 2022
    Valley of the Seine, Giverny, 1912
    Oil · Canvas
    45 3/4 x 46 3/4 in. (116.2 x 116.2 cm.)
    Bonhams · · Lot 35
    $107,475≈ £85,474≈ €100,472Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $60,000–80,000View at Bonhams ↗
  10. Vernon Bridge
    Oil · Canvas
    20 x 24 in. (shaped oval)
    Brunk Auctions · · Lot 728
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $15,000–20,000View at Brunk Auctions ↗
  11. New York Harbor by Theodore Earl Butler, 1917, oil on canvas, sold Nov 2021
    New York Harbor, 1917
    Oil · Canvas
    31 1/2 x 44 in. (80 x 111.8 cm.)
    Bonhams · · Lot 47
    $31,563≈ £23,418≈ €27,821Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $30,000–50,000View at Bonhams ↗
  12. Garden in Giverny, 1928
    Oil · Canvas
    25-1/2 x 21 in.
    Brunk Auctions · · Lot 996
    $34,000≈ £23,954≈ €27,896HammerSign up free to seeEst. $12,000–18,000View at Brunk Auctions ↗
  13. Brooklyn Bridge, New York by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on canvas, sold Nov 2020
    Brooklyn Bridge, New York
    Oil · Canvas
    30 1/8 x 40 1/8in (76.5 x 101.9cm)
    Bonhams · · Lot 14
    $31,563≈ £23,678≈ €26,601Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $20,000–30,000View at Bonhams ↗
  14. Flag Day by Theodore Earl Butler, 1918, oil on canvas, sold Nov 2018
    Flag Day, 1918
    Oil · Canvas
    39 1/2 x 31 1/2in
    Bonhams · · Lot 18
    $552,500≈ £430,732≈ €483,504Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $500,000–700,000View at Bonhams ↗
  15. Vernon Bridge
    Oil · Canvas
    20 x 24 in. (shaped oval)
    Brunk Auctions · · Lot 1578
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $15,000–25,000View at Brunk Auctions ↗
  16. Jimmy at Bath Time, 1893
    Oil · Canvas
    19-1/2 x 24 in.
    Brunk Auctions · · Lot 1575
    $10,000≈ £7,787≈ €8,814HammerSign up free to seeEst. $15,000–25,000View at Brunk Auctions ↗
  17. Sailboats, Upper Bay, New York by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on canvas, offered Nov 2016
    Sailboats, Upper Bay, New York
    Oil · Canvas
    31 3/4 x 40in
    Bonhams · · Lot 38
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $20,000–30,000View at Bonhams ↗
  18. Sailboats, Upper Bay, New York by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on canvas, offered Nov 2015
    Sailboats, Upper Bay, New York
    Oil · Canvas
    31 3/4 x 40in
    Bonhams · · Lot 65
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $40,000–60,000View at Bonhams ↗
  19. Plaine des Ajoux, Giverny by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on canvas, sold May 2015
    Plaine des Ajoux, Giverny
    Oil · Canvas
    23 1/2 x 29in
    Bonhams · · Lot 54
    $18,750≈ £12,070≈ €16,865Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $15,000–25,000View at Bonhams ↗
  20. Farmhouses in Autumn, Giverny by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on canvas, offered May 2015
    Farmhouses in Autumn, Giverny
    Oil · Canvas
    21 1/4 x 25 1/2in
    Bonhams · · Lot 52
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $25,000–35,000View at Bonhams ↗
  21. Mill in the Snow, Giverny by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on canvas, offered Nov 2014
    Mill in the Snow, Giverny
    Oil · Canvas
    23 1/2 x 28 1/2in
    Bonhams · · Lot 48
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $30,000–50,000View at Bonhams ↗
  22. Plaine des Ajoux, Giverny by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on canvas, offered May 2014
    Plaine des Ajoux, Giverny
    Oil · Canvas
    23 1/2 x 29in
    Bonhams · · Lot 15
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $30,000–50,000View at Bonhams ↗
  23. View of the Invalides, Paris by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on board, sold May 2014
    View of the Invalides, Paris
    Oil · Board
    15 x 12 1/2in
    Bonhams · · Lot 14
    $7,500≈ £4,439≈ €5,484Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $6,000–8,000View at Bonhams ↗
  24. The Hunter's Rest, Giverny by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on canvas, sold May 2010
    The Hunter's Rest, Giverny
    Oil · Canvas
    46 1/2 x 46 1/2in
    Bonhams · · Lot 13
    $18,300≈ £12,707≈ €14,867Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $20,000–30,000View at Bonhams ↗
  25. The Hunter's Rest, Giverny by Theodore Earl Butler, oil on canvas, offered Dec 2009
    The Hunter's Rest, Giverny
    Oil · Canvas
    46 1/2 x 46 1/2in
    Bonhams · · Lot 40
    Unsold / did not meet reserveEst. $40,000–60,000View at Bonhams ↗
  26. The Bath, Giverny by Theodore Earl Butler, 1894, oil on canvas, sold May 2007
    The Bath, Giverny, 1894
    Oil · Canvas
    21 1/2 x 25 1/4in
    Bonhams · · Lot 509
    $84,000≈ £42,152≈ €61,742Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $30,000–50,000View at Bonhams ↗
  27. The Plain in Giverny, Apple Trees by Theodore Earl Butler, 1911, oil on canvas, sold Jul 2006
    The Plain in Giverny, Apple Trees, 1911
    Oil · Canvas
    26 x 32 inches
    Coeur d'Alene Art Auction · · Lot 95
    $33,600≈ £18,096≈ €26,498Price realizedSign up free to seeView at Coeur d'Alene Art Auction ↗
  28. Sketch of the Meadow Looking to Great Neck by Theodore Earl Butler, Oil on board scene shows overlapping hills at end of green meadow with stone wall and trees, sold May 2005
    Sketch of the Meadow Looking to Great NeckAttributed to the artist
    Oil · Board
    10-1/2” x 11-1/2”
    James D. Julia · · Lot 915
    $230≈ £121≈ €178Price realizedSign up free to seeEst. $800–1,200View at James D. Julia ↗

Other media by Theodore Earl Butler

Paintings

All Theodore Earl Butler auction results →